SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CHAMBER OF MINES & ENERGY
  • Home
  • About SACOME
    • 2026-2029 Strategy
    • Council
    • Committees
    • Governance
    • Team
    • Initiatives >
      • Playford Trust Scholarships
      • Joint Electricity Purchasing Group
  • Membership
    • SACOME members
    • Annual Sponsors
  • Events
    • Event sponsorship
  • POLICY PRIORITIES
    • Land Access Guides
  • SUBMISSIONS
  • Media & Opinion
  • CONTACT

EPBC Act Tranche 3 Reforms

13 October 2026

Executive Summary
The South Australian Chamber of Mines and Energy (SACOME) welcomes the opportunity to comment on the Tranche 3 regulations and rules supporting implementation of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act) reforms.

South Australia's resources and energy sector will play a critical role in Australia's Future Made in Australia agenda, national energy security and the supply of critical minerals and gas. Environmental regulation should support these outcomes through efficient, and scientifically robust assessment processes while maintaining high environmental standards.

SACOME supports the objective of faster, clearer and more consistent environmental approvals. The Tranche 3 regulations are an opportunity to deliver a simpler, more efficient and more predictable assessment and approval framework, rather than adding new requirements or duplicating work already undertaken.

Achieving this requires a risk-based and proportionate approach that focuses regulatory effort on the environmental impacts that need to be assessed and on what is new or has materially changed. Existing assessments and approvals need to be recognised wherever possible, with State and Commonwealth processes working together rather than assessing the same matters twice. Where environmental impacts have already been assessed through an accredited process, the Commonwealth should rely on those assessments rather than requiring further consideration of the same matters.

These principles are particularly important for resource and energy projects with long development and operating timeframes, where regulatory uncertainty and unnecessary duplication can create significant costs and delays.
 
SACOME recommends that the Australian Government:
  • ensure referral and assessment information requirements are proportionate to environmental risk;
  • limit reassessment of approved projects to proposed changes and any new or increased environmental impacts, with clear requirements for approval extensions;
  • recognise existing environmental assessments undertaken through State and NOPSEMA processes, and increase the use of accredited State assessments to prevent duplication;
  • account for existing tenure, resource potential and projects under development in bioregional planning, and provide certainty around development limits;
  • provide certainty for proponents using restoration contributions and advanced restoration;
  • establish proportionate thresholds for naturally occurring radioactive materials and avoid duplication of State regulation; and
  • publish final requirements and guidance sufficiently in advance of commencement, with transitional arrangements that recognise existing assessment work and approvals.

Recommendations in detail

Project assessment and approvals
1. Ensure referral information requirements are proportionate to environmental risk
The proposed amendments to Schedule 2 establish information requirements for all referrals, with additional requirements under Part 2 for proponents seeking Streamlined Assessment. These requirements will be critical to whether the pathway delivers faster approvals or simply shifts substantial assessment work to the referral stage.
 
SACOME recognises that proponents seeking Streamlined Assessment must provide sufficient information upfront to support an informed approval decision. However, the requirements must be clear and proportionate to the environmental impacts being assessed. Proponents should not have to undertake unnecessary studies or prepare evidence that is disproportionate to the nature, scale and potential significance of those impacts, just to access the Streamlined Assessment pathway.
 
The success of Streamlined Assessment should be measured by the total time and cost of obtaining an approval, not simply compliance with statutory assessment periods. Clear information requirements, proportionate requests for additional information and transparent reporting of actual assessment timeframes are essential to ensuring the reforms deliver genuine efficiency gains.
 
Schedule 2, item 7.01 requires proponents to identify uncertainties in environmental information and whether further assessment could reduce them. Items 11.01-11.03 prescribe additional information about mitigation, monitoring and compensation. These requirements should be sufficiently clear for proponents to understand what evidence is needed before lodging a referral.
 
Unclear or excessive information requirements create two risks for proponents: substantial upfront costs that undermine the benefits of Streamlined Assessment, and the possibility of being moved to a longer assessment pathway because the information initially provided is considered insufficient.
 
SACOME also maintains its opposition to the automatic exclusion of fossil-fuel projects from Streamlined Assessment and bioregional registration. Eligibility for streamlined pathways should be determined by the nature and significance of a project's environmental impacts and its ability to meet the applicable assessment requirements, rather than the nature of the activity alone. SACOME recognises that addressing this exclusion would require legislative change, but considers it an important limitation on the reforms' capacity to deliver consistent, risk-based assessment across the resource and energy sector.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Clearly specify the information and supporting evidence required for Streamlined Assessment, including under Schedule 2, items 7.01 and 11.01-11.03, ensuring requirements are proportionate to the nature, significance and uncertainty of the environmental impacts being assessed.
  • Clarify the scope of environmental history information required, including the relevant period, activities and entities to be considered, and ensure information requirements are proportionate and confined to matters relevant to the assessment or approval decision.
  • Recognise existing assessments and reliable environmental information, including information prepared under State regulatory requirements, where fit for purpose.
  • Ensure terminology and references to the National Environmental Standards are consistent across the regulations, rules and supporting guidance.
  • Publish guidance and worked examples explaining the evidence required to demonstrate consistency with the applicable National Environmental Standards and satisfy the new approval tests, including clear decision-making criteria, how the requirements interact and when existing assessment information can be relied upon.
  • Ensure that minor information gaps or uncertainties that are not material to the approval decision do not, of themselves, result in a project being moved out of the Streamlined Assessment pathway, and that requests for additional information are necessary and proportionate.
  • Establish a single point of responsibility for coordinating each assessment, provide proponents with visibility of assessment progress and publish performance reporting for the new assessment pathways, including total elapsed approval times, the use and duration of stop-clock periods and compliance with statutory timeframes, with a clear escalation process where decisions are delayed.

2. Limit reassessment of existing approvals to what has changed

Resource and energy projects operate over long periods and may require changes to approved activities as they develop. Where a change is proposed, assessment and information requirements should focus on the change and any new or increased environmental impacts, rather than reopening aspects of the project that remain unaffected.

SACOME supports the approach in proposed regulation 5.08(e), which focuses information requirements on additional impacts arising from variations to proposed actions. The same principle should apply to changes sought after a project has received approval.

Proposed regulation 5.05(c)(iv)-(vi) introduces additional information requirements when an extension to an existing approval is sought. These requirements should be implemented proportionately, recognising existing assessments and approval information where the approved activities and their environmental impacts remain materially unchanged.
 
SACOME Recommends the Australian Government:
  • Ensure that changes to approved projects are subject to proportionate assessment requirements, focused on the proposed change and any new or increased environmental impacts, with existing assessments and approval information recognised wherever relevant.
  • Ensure that regulation 5.05 distinguishes between extensions that materially change the environmental impacts of an approved action and those that do not, with information requirements proportionate to the nature and significance of any change.
  • Rely on existing assessments, approval documentation and compliance information, where the approved activities and their environmental impacts remain materially unchanged. Additional studies or reassessment should only be required where necessary to address new or changed environmental circumstances or satisfy the applicable statutory requirements.
3. Avoid duplication of environmental assessments
SACOME supports recognition of existing environmental assessments undertaken through State and Commonwealth regulatory processes. Where environmental impacts have already been adequately assessed, proponents should not be required to repeat studies, provide the same information or have those impacts reassessed unless necessary to satisfy an identified Commonwealth statutory requirement. This principle should apply to accredited State assessment processes, where accreditation must remove duplication in practice, as well as relevant assessments undertaken through NOPSEMA processes.

Where the Commonwealth reaches a different conclusion from an earlier State or NOPSEMA assessment, the reasons should be clearly explained, including the additional evidence or statutory requirements that justify a different finding.

The referral information requirements under Schedule 2 should also recognise relevant assessments and environmental information already prepared through State and NOPSEMA processes. This should apply to State assessments whether or not the relevant processes have been accredited. Transitional arrangements should allow relevant assessment work completed before State accreditation is finalised to be relied upon where it meets the applicable requirements.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • ​Establish a clear pathway and timetable with the South Australian Government for accrediting relevant State assessment processes, with accredited assessments recognised by the Commonwealth.
  • Amend Schedule 2 to expressly state that existing environmental assessments and supporting information prepared under State or Territory legislation may be relied upon to satisfy relevant referral information requirements, where that material is current, relevant and sufficient to meet the Commonwealth's requirements, without requiring duplication of assessment work.
  • Expressly recognise fit-for-purpose environmental assessments undertaken through NOPSEMA processes, so that environmental impacts already adequately assessed are not reassessed, except where additional assessment is necessary to satisfy an identified Commonwealth statutory requirement.
 
Bioregional plans
4. Account for resource potential in development and conservation zones
SACOME supports bioregional planning where it provides a simpler and more predictable pathway for resource projects.

Mineral and energy resources cannot be relocated, and the resource potential of an area may not be fully understood when a bioregional plan is prepared. Zoning decisions made without adequate resource-potential information could prevent future exploration or development before the value of an area is known.

The proposed regulations will require bioregional plans to justify the boundaries of development and conservation zones. Those justifications should take account of resource potential and existing resource interests so that zoning decisions are made with an understanding of their implications for current and future resource development.

For projects in development zones, registration should remain a simple process for demonstrating compliance with the bioregional plan and should not become another project-level assessment.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Require justifications for development and conservation zone boundaries to consider existing tenure and approvals, known resources, prospective resource areas and projects already under development, supported by early consultation with tenure holders and industry (Consultation Paper 2, section 2.2).
  • Ensure bioregional plans can be reviewed when significant new geological information, resource discoveries or changes in strategic resource priorities emerge, rather than relying solely on the five-year review cycle.

5. Provide certainty around development limits

Development limits could create uncertainty for resource projects with long development timeframes. A project may make substantial investment on the basis that it is located within a development zone but be unable to access the registration pathway if available capacity is exhausted before it is ready to register.

The legislation protects projects that are already registered from some subsequent changes to a bioregional plan. Projects that have materially progressed but are not yet registered also need appropriate protection where a development limit is changed.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Require bioregional plans to specify how development capacity is calculated, allocated and monitored, including publishing remaining available capacity.
  • Provide appropriate notice and transitional arrangements when development limits change, including protection for projects that have materially progressed in reliance on the existing development limit but are not yet registered, to the extent permitted under the Act.
  • Provide for a review of development limits before the scheduled five-year review where available capacity is being exhausted earlier than forecast (Consultation Paper 2, section 2.2).
Environmental compensation
6. Ensure responsibility transfers with a restoration contribution
SACOME supports proposed requirements in Part 12D for the delivery and reporting of restoration actions by the Commonwealth Restoration Contributions Holder.
The proposed regulations place responsibility for delivering, maintaining and reporting on restoration actions with the Holder. This should be matched by clear separation between the proponent's obligation to pay the required restoration contribution and the Holder's responsibility for the subsequent delivery and environmental performance. Proponents should not remain responsible for restoration outcomes over which they have no control.

Commonwealth and State compensation requirements should also recognise where the same environmental impact has already been compensated, to avoid duplication.
SACOME understands that the methodology for calculating restoration contributions will be subject to separate consultation. The methodology should be transparent, the amount payable should be known before an approval decision is made, and proponents should have appropriate review rights.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Strengthen Part 12D to clarify that once the required restoration contribution has been paid, responsibility for delivering, maintaining and achieving the required outcomes of the restoration action rests with the Commonwealth Restoration Contributions Holder, rather than the proponent.
  • Ensure Commonwealth restoration contribution requirements recognise compensation provided under State arrangements for the same environmental impact, to prevent duplicate compensation obligations.

7. Provide certainty for registered advanced restoration

SACOME supports advanced restoration, but proponents need certainty that restoration undertaken in advance of project approval will retain its value and can be transferred when ownership or project arrangements change.

Proposed regulations 6C.05 and 6C.06 establish the baseline and expected environmental improvement at registration, but do not expressly protect the assessment methodology and baseline from subsequent regulatory changes. The environmental improvement recognised should reflect the outcomes actually delivered, without retrospectively changing the basis on which the restoration investment was made.

Proposed regulation 6C.09 provides a mechanism for varying registered advanced restoration actions. SACOME supports this flexibility, particularly where changes to restoration timing, activities or site arrangements are necessary.

Regulation 6C.10 allows registration to be suspended or revoked for administrative non-compliance or where restoration is no longer likely to achieve its expected environmental improvement. While suspension can provide an opportunity to remedy deficiencies, the regulations do not require a proportionate response before revocation.

Regulation 6C.11 allows the Minister to approve transfers where considered appropriate, without specifying the grounds for refusal. This creates uncertainty for project sales, corporate restructures and other changes in ownership.
  
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Ensure the assessment methodology and baseline accepted under regulations 6C.05 and 6C.06 are preserved, so subsequent regulatory changes do not retrospectively alter the basis for recognising environmental improvements, while continuing to account for actual environmental outcomes.
  • Require suspension and revocation decisions under regulation 6C.10 to be proportionate to the nature and materiality of the non-compliance, with appropriate notice, an opportunity to respond and reasonable opportunities to remedy deficiencies where practicable.
  • Establish clear, objective criteria for transfers under regulation 6C.11, with decisions based on matters relevant to the incoming party's ability to fulfil the registered obligations.
  • Establish clear criteria for determining whether registered advanced restoration can be used to meet a project's environmental compensation requirements, with any refusal based on specified eligibility requirements and the environmental outcomes achieved.

8. Avoid unnecessary regulation and duplication for radiological exposure

The Commonwealth proposes to introduce activity thresholds for mining, processing, stockpiling and disposal involving naturally occurring radioactive material (NORM) under section 22(1A)(e) of the EPBC Act. However, the proposed thresholds have not been included in the exposure draft regulations. Without these details, industry cannot assess which activities would be captured or the implications for existing and proposed resource projects.

South Australia already regulates radiological risks associated with mining and mineral processing. The new Commonwealth requirements should be proportionate to environmental risk and avoid unnecessary duplication of existing State assessment, monitoring and reporting requirements, particularly for non-uranium projects.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Publish the proposed NORM activity thresholds for industry consultation before they are finalised, with sufficient information to assess their application to mining, processing, stockpiling and disposal activities. The thresholds should be risk-based and avoid unnecessarily capturing low-risk activities.
  • Recognise relevant assessments, monitoring and information completed under South Australian radiation regulation where Commonwealth assessment is required, rather than duplicating existing requirements (Consultation Paper 4, section 4.2).

9. Provide sufficient notice and certainty during transition
​
The exposure draft regulations are scheduled to commence on 1 December 2026. Proposed regulations in 20.21-20.33 (Schedule 1, Part 2) establish transitional arrangements, including applying the new referral requirements to referrals made on or after commencement.

Proponents preparing projects for referral need sufficient notice of the final requirements to avoid having to revise or repeat work already undertaken. This is particularly important for resource projects involving lengthy environmental studies and assessment preparation.

The transition arrangements should also provide certainty for projects approved before commencement of the reforms. Where proponents subsequently seek to vary or extend those approvals, they should have clear guidance on which requirements apply and how existing assessments and approval documentation will be recognised.
 
SACOME recommends the Australian Government:
  • Clarify how amended information requirements, including regulation 5.05, apply to variations and extensions of approvals granted before commencement, when additional assessment or information may be required, and how existing assessments and approvals will be recognised.
  • Publish the final regulations, referral and assessment requirements, methods, calculators and supporting guidance sufficiently in advance of commencement to allow proponents to prepare for the new system.
  • Ensure transitional arrangements recognise substantive assessment work already undertaken under existing requirements, where it remains relevant and sufficient, without requiring unnecessary duplication.

CONTACT THE SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CHAMBER OF MINES & ENERGY
​e: 
[email protected]  |  t: +61 (0)8 8202 9999
​
​3rd Floor, 115 King William Street, Adelaide South Australia 5000
_
​Follow SACOME on social media
SACOME Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • About SACOME
    • 2026-2029 Strategy
    • Council
    • Committees
    • Governance
    • Team
    • Initiatives >
      • Playford Trust Scholarships
      • Joint Electricity Purchasing Group
  • Membership
    • SACOME members
    • Annual Sponsors
  • Events
    • Event sponsorship
  • POLICY PRIORITIES
    • Land Access Guides
  • SUBMISSIONS
  • Media & Opinion
  • CONTACT